Legal Question in Real Estate Law in Massachusetts
Eviction of Tenancy at Will
Currently our landlord has gone through a messy divorce and subsequently, we(the tenants) have been left out in the dark as to our situation. We are tenants at will and have been dealing with locks being changed by his wifes lawyers, inspectors in and out and potential buyers of the property. For the past 1yr we having been paying rent to him but the recent events have been without his knowledge by her. Now I have received a noticed evicting us from our homes with a 30 days notice. The letter was from HER lawyer, and was NOT certified but cited MGL c186 section 12. He won't return calls nor do I know if I should continue paying rent. What rights do we have? Does the fact we have been paying rent to him have any influence in our tenancy? MGL 186 section 12 cites that all tentants have the right to remain in apartment until order by a judge to vacate premises? Something really seems fishy with this entire situation and any help would be useful please!! We can't afford lawyers and may be forced to search elsewhere for a new home but that is also expensive in the area.
3 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Eviction of Tenancy at Will
What a mess! Has anyone notified you clearly of who
owns the damned building? Who is it? When were you notified?
What exactly did the notice say was the reason? That's critically important.
What did it say, exactly, about Ch. 186, sec. 12?
What date was the notice delivered, by whom, to whom, and what dates did the notice give for you to
leave? Did it offer an opportunity to catch up the rent or say something
about that? Were you in arrears in rent when it was sent?
You probably can't afford not to hire an attorney. Tenant attorneys -- specialists,
believe me! -- are surprisingly cheap and often don't cost you any money in the long
run since they often get their fees paid by the landlord under court order or taken out
of rent that they collect from you (instead of having you pay the landlord) while you
fight an eviction, often by agreement of the landlord in the context of an eventual
settlement agreement.
What city do you live in? Send me e-mail directly. If you're in Boston
or close thereto, I can put you in touch with some great tenant defense
lawyers, including one who actually wrote legislation which helped to create
Chapter 186, the lawyer I first studied landlord / tenant law under.
Don't expect to have to be gone no matter what in literally 30 days.
With the help of a decent lawyer, you can probably stay a long time
(for no change in rent).
Where did you read that Ch. 186 sec. 12 says everyone can stay until ordered out by a judge?
It doesn't say that, but it's the truth anyway: noone is ever evicted in Mass. without an
order by a judge!
Here's that section for you to read.
[ See next message from me! ]
Stu Williams, 21 Walter St., Newton, MA 02459, [email protected], tel. (617) 527-0050
and fax the notice to me at 527-1763 if I'm to look at it.
Stuart Williams
Law Offices of Stuart J. Williams
21 Walter St.
Re: Eviction of Tenancy at Will
Here's for your reading pleasure:
Chapter 186: Section 12. Notice to determine estate at will.
Section 12. Estates at will may be determined by either party by three months' notice in writing for that purpose given to the other party; and, if the rent reserved is payable
at periods of less than three months, the time of such notice shall be sufficient if it is equal to the interval between the days of payment or thirty days, whichever is longer.
Such written notice may include an offer to establish a new tenancy for the same premises on terms different from that of the tenancy being terminated and the validity of
such written notice shall not be affected by the inclusion of such offer. In case of neglect or refusal to pay the rent due from a tenant at will, fourteen days' notice to quit,
given in writing by the landlord to the tenant, shall be sufficient to determine the tenancy; provided, that the tenancy of a tenant who has not received a similar notice from
the landlord within the twelve months next preceding the receipt of such notice shall not be determined if the tenant, within ten days after the receipt thereof, pays or
tenders to the landlord, the landlord's attorney, or the person to whom the tenant customarily pays rent, the full amount of any rent due. Every notice to determine an estate
at will for nonpayment of rent shall contain the following notification to the tenant: "If you have not received a notice to quit for nonpayment of rent within the last twelve
months, you have a right to prevent termination of your tenancy by paying or tendering to your landlord, your landlord's attorney or the person to whom you customarily
pay your rent the full amount of rent due within ten days after your receipt of this notice." If any notice to determine an estate at will for nonpayment of rent shall fail to
contain such notification, the time within which the tenant receiving the notice would be entitled to pay or tender rent pursuant to this section shall be extended to the day
the answer is due in any action by the landlord to recover possession of the premises. Failure to include such notice shall not otherwise affect the validity of the said notice.
If the neglect or refusal to pay the rent due was caused by a failure or delay of the federal government, the commonwealth or any municipality, or any departments,
agencies or authorities thereof, in the mailing or delivery of any subsistence or rental payment, check or voucher other than a salary payment to either the tenant or the
landlord, the court in any action for possession shall continue the hearing not less than seven days in order to furnish notice of such action to the appropriate agency and
shall, if all rent due with interest and costs of suit has been tendered to the landlord within such time, treat the tenancy as not having been terminated.
Stuart Williams
Law Offices of Stuart J. Williams
21 Walter St.
Re: Eviction of Tenancy at Will
Keep paying rent. The notice to quit is the first step in an eviction. They must still go
to court and still must get a judge's order. A judge can allow you months to move out.
I suggest that you either hire a lawyer if you wish to remain or start looking for a new
place to live. However, if you are looking for a new place in good faith, I don't think a
judge will evict you before you find a new apartment as long as you keep paying rent.
Alan Pransky
Law Office of Alan J. Pransky
20 Eastbrook Road