Legal Question in Criminal Law in Michigan

My Son was searched at school for pot

My son was searched by the superintendent at the High School after a student told that he had pot in his backpack. The superintendent called and told me they were doing the search, per my son's request. He also said ''I do not need your permission, I am just calling to inform you of the situation''. He was was ticketed for possession of pot and cigarettes. I received the hearing notification from the courthouse. I called to request an attorney and was told I one would not be appointed until after the preliminary hearing, if he pleads not guilty. I want to know if it was legal for them to search my son? I reviewed his handbook and it only stated that the locker could be searched as it is school property. I have heard that they have the same parental rights, but as a parent, I would not have reported it to the police. Since then, the teachers have had a negative attitude towards him, a ''popular'' athlete threw a carton of milk at him, with no ramifications, and then accused my son of stealing money out of his locker. Would it be best to plead guilty and be done with it or plead innocent and get the court appointed attorney? Also the form said it is based on income or if I refuse to supply one. Is this true?


Asked on 3/09/06, 4:14 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Neil O'Brien Eaton County Special Assistant Prosecuting Attorney

Re: My Son was searched at school for pot

It is not illegal for the school officials to search a student's locker, backpack or other container on the school's property.

The only issue along this line that I have had to sift through is whether the school is doing the search as an "agent" of law enforcement - i.e., the police asked/told the school to do the search. The problem here is that police searches - unlike school official searches - may conflict with constitutional protections, like the right to be protected from unreasonable searches and seizures. Cops have to have a search warrant or a viable exception to the search warrant requirement. The cops cannot do an "end run" around that requirement by directing private citizens to do it for them.

But when school officials are doing searches like this, they are not doing it in order to further a criminal/delinquency investigation. They are trying to protect the school environment so other students don't get hurt. This is just like a parent who searches the kid's bedroom: it's to protect the child and others in the home from the contraband. They can do searches that cops might not be able to do without a judge's approval. The fact that the school officials (and even parents in similar home searches) contact police afterwards and turn the evidence over the the cops does not retroactively make the search illegal. The focus has to be on whether they were acting as an agent of the police when the search occurred.

There is no harm in pleading not guilty and getting a lawyer's advice as to the best course of action. You might even be able to consult with a lawyer in private practice for free or a nominal amount before your son's first court hearing, but you ought to get a copy of the police report first from the prosecutor or the court so the attorney you talk to can see what the police say the facts are.

Read more
Answered on 3/10/06, 8:36 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Criminal Law questions and answers in Michigan