Legal Question in Civil Litigation in Michigan

Pro Hac Vice

I have a civil lawsuit in a District Court in Michigan I am A Pro Se' plaintiff against a large corporation. This corporation has allready asked and recieved permission from the court to allow two Pro Hac Vice attorneys from a firm in Atlanta, Ga Now they want to add a third Pro Hac Vice Attorney. Is this a bit extreme and how should I handle my objection to this intimidating ploy. I believe I have a good case and it is set for A Jury Trial Next month.

Thank You


Asked on 3/20/03, 12:05 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

William Stern William Stern, P.C.

Re: Pro Hac Vice

Simply object that there should be one lawyer in charge of the case and you should not be exposed to such hassrassment. Tell the judge that as far as you care concerned, there are 30,000 lawyers in Michigan and they should be able to find a local lawyer. Bill Stern

Read more
Answered on 3/20/03, 12:54 pm
Don Darnell Darnell & Lulgjuraj, P.C.

Re: Pro Hac Vice

You can respond to the motion to deny an appearance by a third out-of-state lawyer, but you'll probably lose since the court already admitted two others.

Sounds like they intend to "outlawyer" you. Nothing wrong or unethical about that, but as a non lawyer you probably won't be able to anticipate every contingency in a jury trial. On a side note, if you are hoping that the jury will have simpathy for you because you are in pro per, I would rethink that position, people don't sit on juries often, and they either think it's an inconvience or an honor - either way, they want to see a good show and don't want to waste thier time. I've had two trials now against persons in pro per, and both were a miserable experience. Not because of the outcome (both went better than they would have my oppenent been an attorney). But it was such an ordeal each time the judge would rule against my in pro per opponent, because they could not appreciate why they couldn't get certain evidence in, or why most of thier case was dismissed on directed verdict.

I would advise you to get counsel, no matter how strong you beleive the case is, the evidence is, or whatever. It will be money well spent.

Don Darnell

Read more
Answered on 3/20/03, 4:26 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More General Civil Litigation questions and answers in Michigan