Legal Question in Criminal Law in Minnesota
Limitations of a Search Warrant
If a seach warrant was issued for a stolen computer and during the search a gun was found in a room not belonging to the defendant and he stated that he touched the gun but it was not his. Is this search warrant valid for court use or is it a violation of privacy
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Limitations of a Search Warrant
Police executing a search warrant are limited to searching for items within the scope of the search warrant. So, for example, if a search warrant only authorized a search for a television set, police would not have legal authority to search inside pockets of clothing in a closet. Knowing this police typically try to get a search warrant with broad scope. A defense lawyer will look at the search warrant carefully to determine if its scope was exceeded in the police search.
If police are looking for a computer, specified in a search warrant, then see a handgun in plain view, it is possible it may have been legally seized as evidence -- depending upon other factors. However, if the gun was found in a pocket of a jacket in a closet, it would seem more likely the search exceeded the scope of the warrant (assuming the warrant only authorized a search for a computer).
Re: Limitations of a Search Warrant
Law nforcement ay conduct a search that is within the scope of the warrant. If they locate other contraband in that search, it may certainly be used to bring additional charges. The question may be whether the scope of the warrant was exceeded. Once the computer that they are looking for has been located, or any other items listed on the warrant, the search must end.
For a consultation call 612.240.8005
Related Questions & Answers
-
Excessive sentence how would u get a sentence review in minnesota? Asked 2/26/08, 8:55 pm in United States Minnesota Criminal Law