Legal Question in Family Law in Minnesota
Divorce Decree states...
In my husband's divorce decree it states that he and his ex-wife agreed that their 3 children were to be raised Catholic. My husband and I are avid church goers and we love the Lord but we do not attend the Catholic church. My husband switched churches about 2 months after the divorce was final. His ex-wife does not even go to church so this leaves the children having to attend mass alone. What can we do to amend this to allow for the children to attend the church their dad belongs to? His ex is being very difficult with this which I find ironice because she doesn't even go. She just knows it is a bone of contention!!! Can the decree amended without her getting her way again? What is the process and is there anyway to handle this without going to court again? She was the cause of the divorce by being unfaithful and my husband divorced her - if that makes any difference.
(We live in SD and she lives in MN. He has one child with him and she has the other two. They alternate caring for them every other weekend.)
1 Answer from Attorneys
Re: Divorce Decree states...
I presume from your question that the divorce was entered in Minnesota, and not South Dakota.
Your question is an important one, since the issue of "values" comes up with some regularity, whether religious or personal values.
Although the decree may require the child to be "raised Catholic," that does not prohibit your husband from taking the children to a church of his own choosing, although perhaps they cannot be "confirmed" in that church. I would want to see the language of the Decree, but it would be rather unusual if it provided for attendance at a specific church. Like most decrees, it probably contains only a general statement describing the religious preference of the parties at the time of divorce. This does not ordinarily mean both parents must attend a specific church, in a specific denomination, nor does necessarily prevent the children from attending another church with one of their parents. Instead, the question is usually in which church the children will be baptized, confirmed, etc. If the mother is insistent that the children be raised Catholic, she has every right to take them to a church of her choosing, and your husband cannot try to move them into another denomination.
If you are very concerned about the matter, you could bring a motion to modify this provision of the Decree, although I think that is probably unnecessary. I think it wise to simply take the children to your own church. If the exwife does nothing (but complain), then after a time you will have established the factual basis necessary for a motion in court, should that become necessary. In my experience, many lawyers are too quick to rush to court, and don't take time to cultivate the facts before the matter reaches court -- if it gets there at all.
If you have further questions or concerns, you can certainly contact me. However, if the divorce decree was entered in South Dakota, this matter should be addressed by a lawyer in that state.