Legal Question in Legal Ethics in Minnesota

PI attorney took advantage of my TBI condition

My PI attorney submitted a demand for settlement to a home

improvement center for several hundred thousand dollars

BEFORE he reviewed my medical history. After reviewing my

medical history my attorney pressured me into settling for

$50,000 from which 1/3 will go to him and possibly the entire

remaining amount going to subrogation claims - leaving me little

or nothing in compensation. He also told me that I am bound by

law to sign the release for the settlement and he won't honor my

repeated requests to be informed of the amount that will be paid

out in subrogation claims. Further, over a 4 and a half year period

my attorney did next to nothing to keep me informed of the status

of my case despite frequent request for him to do so. Is this not

legal malpractice or at least a breech of legal ethics and

professional responsibility? What can I do?


Asked on 12/03/03, 3:28 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

Charles Aspinwall Charles S. Aspinwall, J.D., LLC

Re: PI attorney took advantage of my TBI condition

Contact your local bar association. They know what to do, and will advise you in how to proceed with your complaint.

Read more
Answered on 12/03/03, 8:50 pm
Regina Mullen Legal Data Services, PLC

Re: PI attorney took advantage of my TBI condition

The demand for settlement should have been in good faith, but that doesn't mean that settling for $50K is unreasonable. Your case may not be nearly as good as you think it is, or it may cost so much to get the facts out there, that you'll end up with little after the jury verdict even if you win.

Your lawyer can't MAKE you sign anything. It's 100% your choice. If you don't like the terms, get another lawyer. It's done all the time; the only thing is, you need to make sure that the contingency fee rights of the lawyer who got you this far are fully taken care of. He has a right to receive 1/3 of any amount up to $50K and his expenses,--your new attorney will get the rest of whatever fee remains.

Few people, though, will be willing to take this case if it's only a few thousand dollars off what is objectively reasonable. Still, you are entitled to a second opinion. Pay another lawyer a few hundred to review the file, it may be worth it.

Read more
Answered on 12/04/03, 6:16 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Legal Ethics & Professional Responsibility questions and answers in Minnesota