Legal Question in Criminal Law in Mississippi

withdrawal of statement

If I gave a police statement against someone, but I refuse to testify against them, can the statement still be used in their trial? Why or why not?


Asked on 6/12/09, 9:38 am

2 Answers from Attorneys

Albert Pettigrew Law Offices Ph 228-875-8736

Re: withdrawal of statement

It cannot be used against a defendant because it would violate the defendant's right to confront a witness. However, if you gave a false statement, you could be responsible for obstruction of justice or perjury. To protect yourself from perjury, you will have to recant the statement before the government acts in reliance on it. However, a recantation may not protect you from an offense of making a false statement. If you gave a truthful statement but refuse to testify, the court can hold you in contempt and put you in jail until you are agreeable to testify.

Read more
Answered on 6/12/09, 2:16 pm
Wayne Woodall Wayne Woodall Attorney

Re: withdrawal of statement

The statement cannot be used in a criminal trial against the Defendant in most cases unless you are available for the Court so that the parties can "Cross Examine" you about the truth of the statement. However, you cannot "simply decide not to testify" unless the party about whom the statement was made was either a client of yours (as a lawyer) or a patient of yours (as a Physician) or unless you are the defendant's Pastor/Priest. Otherwise, you have no "right" to refuse to testify and the State can compel your testimony. If you refuse to testify then you may be incarcerated by the Judge for refusing his instructions at Court to "answer the question" presented by the Prosecutor.

Read more
Answered on 6/12/09, 5:05 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Criminal Law questions and answers in Mississippi