Legal Question in Construction Law in New Jersey

Unfinished Pool

I entered into a contract with a pool company in July 2006 to build a custom shape in ground gunite pool with an extensive rock waterfall, slide, hot tub and fire effects. The pool was originally supposed to be complete by November 2006 with a worst case completion of early spring 2007. Progress was much slower than expected on the pool and when I complained to the pool company the owner gave me a verbal guarantee that it would be done by May 31, 2007. I have paid $95,000 of the total $120,000 cost of the pool and have gotten estimates from 2 other pool companies to fix the problems with work already done and complete the pool in the $60,000 to $80,000 range. I spoke to the owner of the company and told him that if I didn’t see significant progress on the pool in the near future I would take legal action and get someone else to finish the pool. He told me he was ready and willing to finish the pool and if he was ordered off the job would take legal action. The conversation ended with him planning on having work start on Monday. That was 2 weeks ago and nothing has been done.

Can I get out of this contract?

Should I sue him for the cost to complete the pool?


Asked on 8/24/07, 5:06 pm

4 Answers from Attorneys

Re: Unfinished Pool

OK, you have a problem, and sorry, you really should get an attorney now, and I'm not saying that because I'm looking for work, I'd tell my brother the same thing... First, you need to put your position in writing and send it to him regular and CRR mail. The chances of litigation are about 99%, because even if you get someone else, and the contractor doesn't sue, you will end up out of pocket a lot more than $120,000, and the new contractor will most likely tell you there are numerous items completed improperly. Based upon the limited facts given, you should be able to sue for breach of contract, fraud, consumer fraud, negligence, and even windfall. You can also sue for the lost of the beneficial use of the pool for the entire 2007 season. Depending on where you are, I'm a construction engineer also, and I concentrate on construction matters (surprise), so call if you want. Good luck whatever you do, but call someone OR put everything in writing NOW! You'll be glad you did when you get to trial.

Read more
Answered on 8/25/07, 12:32 am
Henry Chan Wilson & Chan, LLP

Re: Unfinished Pool

Your situation happens much too often and gives conractors a bad reputation. As stated in other responses, your contractor is in breach of the contract. Hire an attorney asap and send the contractor a notice/demand/deadline letter.

Let me know if I can assist you.

Read more
Answered on 8/26/07, 7:15 pm
Alani Golanski Alani Golanski, Esq.

Re: Unfinished Pool

You should probably have an attorney contact the contractor, and explain that the contractor is in breach, that this breach is a material (very significant) one, thus entitling you to terminate the contract, find an alternative way of completing the work, and bring an action for all of your damages. Our firm focuses on contract disputes, and practices in New Jersey.

Read more
Answered on 8/24/07, 5:25 pm
Robert Davies The Davies Law Firm, P.A.

Re: Unfinished Pool

This happens much too often. Contractors are pretty good people in general, but jokers like this unfortunately cause a lot of harm.

He is in breach. He did not do what he was supposed to. You might be able to persuade a judge and a jury that he has abandoned the job; that would make him liable under the NJ consumer fraud laws, very bad for him, and might get you punitive damages and all your attorney's fees. Not certain on that.

Get a lawyer. the lawyer should write a really clear and harsh letter to him to try to get him to complete the job. Then, you have someone else finish it, and sue. This has to be done right.

I am in Hackensack, not too far from you; let me know if you want me to assist.

My contact information can be obtained from the links below, just click on the Attorney Profile link. Let my secretary know you found me through LawGuru.

Disclaimer: Your question and any response does NOT create an attorney-client relationship between you and this law firm. You can not rely on the statements made by an attorney given over the internet. The exact facts of your situation, including facts which you have not mentioned in your question, may completely change the result for your situation.

Read more
Answered on 8/24/07, 5:41 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Construction Law questions and answers in New Jersey