Legal Question in Technology Law in New Mexico

Do I own my intellectual property on the web?

I am having a dispute with a website that includes computer game reviews submitted by registered members of the site. I do not work for them. They have threatened me because I have posted my reviews on another website. There are no Terms of Agreement to read and verify when making a new member account. This leads me to believe that they are wrong, since as a member I never agreed to any kind of deal. Furthermore, there are no Official Terms of Agreement anywhere on the site for that matter.

One of the editors posted his own TOA on the message board a couple months ago. This seems unprofessional and it still does not prove that they can control my written work. I became a member long before this post existed, and I never agreed upon it. The editors seem to think that by posting their individual terms on a message board that is frequented by less than 1% of the site (literally) makes their rules law.

There exists no Terms of Agreement or Service to read and sign when making a new account. There exists no reference to the ownership of submitted reviews whatsoever, excluding one post on the message board. The reviews that I wrote are my work and I believe they belong to me, and that I shouldn't be pressured into where I use them.


Asked on 11/18/03, 11:32 am

1 Answer from Attorneys

Charles Aspinwall Charles S. Aspinwall, J.D., LLC

Re: Do I own my intellectual property on the web?

Your original creations belong to you, unless you sell or assign specific ownership rights to others. Posting original materials on one website does not preclude you from posting the same materials on another website, absent your sale or assignment of your rights. No one can prohibit you from posting. The website you mention may, however, enact its own internal rules, and exlude you from membership if you don't follow those rules. That is a matter of voluntary acceptance by those who subscribe, and a lack of subscription by those who don't, not of ownership of intellectual property.

Read more
Answered on 11/18/03, 11:46 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Computer & Technology Law questions and answers in New Mexico