Legal Question in Banking Law in New York

bank problem

We went to Chase bank to open a Checking account. They asked for 2 IDs, My wife gave a Florida Drivers Lic. and her work ID, I gave my Florida Drivers Lic. and my Navigation Lic. (Captains Lic.) from Puerto Rico. The first question he asked,

1. Are you US. Citizen? I said, all puertorricans are citizens....

Then he said ok,,, picked up the phone and called Chase bank central(I guess, or his boss) and ask if we accept lic. from P.R., I dont know what the person said in the other line but the reply saying but is from Puerto Rico... during this I gave him P.R. Drivers Lic. and said we dont cant accept this. I gave him my Social Security Card.. and he still didnt accept it... I showed him my CHASE VISA CARD. and he said I am sorry.

But what about my Fl drivers lic. and still didnt want to accept it.... Until I had no choice to leave.....

Everybody was looking and I really felt bad.. like if I was a ilegal immigrant or something...

I went to another bank and didnt ask any question and accepted my P.R. Drivers lic. like any another lic from any other state of the US...

Why my wife with her Fl lic. and her work ID was ok,, even work ID is not government ID.. but I provided 3 ID all from US Government and this wasnt ok???


Asked on 7/24/08, 9:39 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Steve Brodsky Esq. CheapNewYorkLLC.com

Re: bank problem

You'd be surprised how different banks interpret rules differently. Some banks are simply not consumer-friendly. Apparently, Chase is one of those banks. When my clients tell me stories like this, I tell them to do exactly what you did: go to another bank. There are no shortage of banks to choose from. Shame on Chase for making you feel so bad.

By the way, you may want to share your story with the good people at The Consumerist, http://consumerist.com. They may post your story to warn others about the poor treatment you received at Chase.

Read more
Answered on 7/25/08, 9:05 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Banking Law questions and answers in New York