Legal Question in Criminal Law in New York

dismissal

on 8/20/07 i went to court;my lawyer postponed for another court date 10/18/07 by stating the prosecutor wasn''t ready because he only had a secondarywitness a {cop}not the complaintant who is listed on the complaint report and no longer works for the company no witness from the company. my lawyer states he added up all the court days and it is well over 90 days. he is asking for a miss trial or dismissal shouldn't this be automatically dismiss.my lawyer says it;s possible.what about the 6th amendment or a speedy trial? i was arrested on 11/13/06 my first court date was 12/18/06 .i have been to court a total of 9 times in 11 months for petty larceny.please give me advice also what is the statue of limations in which i can bring forth a civial lawsuit for unlawful arrest :and wrongful termination.my store manager even said i did nothing wrong. thank you


Asked on 8/22/07, 3:11 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Anthony Colleluori The Law Offices of Anthony J. Colleluori & Associates PLLC

Re: dismissal

Wow, you have a lot here.

Ok, a petite larceny is an a misdemeanor. Under the statute in NY (CPL SECTION 30.30) the prosecution has 90 days from arraignment to act. If the defense either requests the adjournment or consents to it, then that time is excluded from the 90 days.

Check with your lawyer or look at the court's file to see to whom the time was charged for each adjournment. You can look it up at the Webcrims site for NY COurts.

The 6th amendments protection is far longer than the NY Statute. As far as the statute of limitations is concerned it is 3 years on an A misdemeanor.

Finally you must file a notice of claim for false arrest within 90 days as a condition precedent to filing a claim within a year+90 days, or else proceed by way of a federal civil rights lawsuit which has no 90 day condition precedent but must be brought within 3 years of the arrest.

Further be aware that the proper lawsuit may be for malicious prosecution under the federal statute but if you want to succeed that way, then you must not be convicted. You cannot even accept an ACOD. It must be clearly a decision in your favor.

If you wish to discuss the civil rights case and ramifications you may contact me through the links below.

Good luck.

Read more
Answered on 8/22/07, 11:59 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Criminal Law questions and answers in New York