Legal Question in Family Law in New York

Child Custody

After finding out my ex was pregnant, she confessed to me in front of several witnesses that she had be unfaithful during our relationship with her ex and now it�s unclear whether the child is mine. She claims me as the father, insists on having the child and is willing to take the necessary paternity tests. I as well as several other witnesses feel she is not in a mentally stable state. She comes for a traumatically broken home, were she was exposed to an environment without discipline, profanity etc. I feel that this affected her judgment and mental stability in a negative way and that she would not provide a stable environment for the unborn child. I know my legal obligation, but I would not rest easy knowing that safety of this child may be a risk or I�m paying child support and contributing to her �way of life�. I would like to have custody of the child and although I would be a single father I would have the full support of my Family, which is willing and eager to raise the child, with me. What are my legal rights in this manner and how could I go about gaining custody? Does the court take into account paternal misconduct as not being in the �best interest of the child?� Any advice received would be greatly appreciated.


Asked on 9/18/01, 3:20 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

John Hayes The Law Office of John M. Hayes

Re: Child Custody

Unfortunately, it seems to take a long time between when you submit your question and when it then gets "circulated" for answers.

It is difficult to sort out who was married to whom, if anyone, w/regard to this pregnancy. It does make some difference if anyone was, or is, legally married to the woman.

Now-a-days, single, out-of-wedlock fathers who "step up" and assert an interest in custody of infants because they {the fathers} claim the mother is "unfit" do get treated a little bit better than in the past.

Having said that, one should also point out that a lot depends on *where* you are - - the policies & procedures & 'outcomes' in Family Court are not at all uniform from county to county / from city to country.

If you can afford to hire an attorney, you should try to learn as much as you can about the available choices of attorneys in your area. In my estimation, the chances of succeeding in a case such as yours appears to be

{note that important 'qualifier' = "appears to be"}

depends largely on How It Is Presented. If you cannot afford an attorney, you will have an opportunity to have an attorney assigned to you, free of charge. However, you still need to begin to get "clear" in your mind that a case such as yours has to be presented carefully: put otherwise, it will not work to go charging into court yelling that this woman is an unstable nut case because she grew up in a home where profanity was used. That tactic simply won't work.

Note this important aspect: if you are not legally married, now, she can 'claim' you are the father, but she cannot get you "named" as such on the birth certificate without your active participation. Although one school of thought might be to urge you to act quickly, another school of thought might be to suggest that you wait to see what the woman does, after the baby is born.

Again - if you can hire an attorney, _now_ is not too soon to begin to seek his/her professional advice and counsel.

Good luck.

Regards, etc.,

J. M. Hayes

>>--> The foregoing amounts to musings and observations based on some years familiarity with the 'day-to-day' operation of the law with regard to the issues involved In The Most General sense; my remarks should not be thought of as "legal advice and counsel" in the formal sense of that phrase, since there is, in fact, no 'attorney / client' relationship existing between us. <-<<

Read more
Answered on 11/05/01, 8:28 pm
Amy L. Finch, 845-362-0387 Amy L. Finch, Attorney and Counselor at Law

Re: Child Custody

I can understand your concern. You can and should sue if you are truely concerned about the child's well being. Although you can handle things like this by yourself in Family Court, I would suggest you hire an attorney. Having a child removed from it's mother is an uphill battle, and you need the assistance of a qualified attorney.

Read more
Answered on 11/06/01, 8:45 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Family Law, Divorce, Child Custody and Adoption questions and answers in New York