Legal Question in Intellectual Property in New York

Re: Copying a Music CD

Technically, yes.

Re: Copying a Music CD

Mr. Browde's answer is too brief for the issue. In fact while generally he is correct, under your description it appears that your use may be fair use.

The following from C/Net Review is a more complete answer:

Can you legally put a collection of songs together and give it to your lover? It depends on what state you live in and whether you're married. No, that's not true, but if you are married, living together, or close friends, it might help make the case that the copy was made for a "personal use." Technically, giving away a mix CD is illegal, but there are exceptions:

1.Online agreements: For example, legal sites such as iTunes and Napster.com encourage you to make a CD mix or playlist, but their terms and conditions contract limits the number of copies to seven (7). As for then giving one of those copies away to a lover, Napster considers that an acceptable "personal use."

2. Audio CD-Rs: There is a relatively unknown exception under the AHRA that legally allows you to make a digital copy of your music and give it to that perfect man or woman. Both of the following conditions must be met:

You must record the songs on a special Audio CD-R (or for that matter on a MiniDisc or a digital tape). Audio CD-Rs look virtually identical to regular CDs except for the price tag. An Audio CD-R will cost you anywhere from 2 to 10 times as much per CD. The rationale goes: Between you and the manufacturer of the CD, the required royalty taxes have already been paid, as opposed to regular CDs, where the music royalty taxes haven't been paid. It takes some searching, but you'll find Audio or Music CDs at your local RadioShack or Office Max.

You must also record the mix using a "digital audio recording device." Again, under the AHRA, computers don't count. You need to use a standalone CD burner. Those devices are acceptable because, here again, the royalty taxes have already been collected. For example, Sony, Panasonic, and Philips sell standalones.

I think you are more than likely safe as long as you only record one cd and give it away to a close friend or relative and not sell it.

With that information let me remind you that:

The information you obtain at this site and on this post is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. We invite you to contact us and welcome your calls, letters and electronic mail. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send any confidential information to us until such time as an attorney-client relationship has been established.

Good luck.