Legal Question in Employment Law in New York
I recently had a hearing because my former employer claimed I was fired for misconduct. At the hearing, my former employer stated under oath that I was fired for poor work performance (which is what I claimed when I first filed for UI benefits)...they hired an outside consulting firm that resulted in them contesting my benefits. They claimed I was fired for using the company computer for personal use. I was able to show that this is a policy that is NOT enforced on any employee in the company. Once the ALJ heard her say that I was terminated for poor performance; that means the decision should go in my favor...correct?
1 Answer from Attorneys
Generally speaking, unemployment benefits are denied for misconduct. There is no way for an attorney to reach into the mind of an ALJ and to give you a definitive answer on how she or he will rule on your particular case.