Legal Question in Real Estate Law in New York
Need to break a trust...
Over 20 years ago,my brother and I were named to the deed of our house by our mother duing a divorce where she gave her half of the house to us.The deed states that we own 50% witch will be held in trust by our father.I am now 30 years old and we would like him to buy us out. Our lawyer filed a motion to break the trust that my mother,brother & I signed.The judge threw it out saying that he owns the house until he dies of feels fit to buy us out. What should I do?Do you know of any case law ruling in my favor? Do I have any rights what so ever? I would like to appeal the judges decision but it will be very costly. I need to know if it is worth it.Please help???
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Need to break a trust...
I will need to take a look at the deed, the trust and of course the judge's ruling to determine what your options would be. It may be that the father has a life estate on the deed which would create a problem for you if you tried to transfer your interest or ask him to buy you out.
Should you like me to review these documents to give you a better answer, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Kind regards,
Peter Moulinos
Re: Need to break a trust...
It may be worthwhile to pursue Appeal of the Court decision dismissing your application if you can show that:
a) The Trust or its terms and conditions were entered due fraud, misrepresentation or duress.
b) The "Trust" was or can be deemed a revocable Trust; and
c) Your mother made other or further written statements or declarations (ie., a will or other document), clarifying the terms and conditions of the trust).
d) Your parent's Divorce Judgment, Stipulation or Agreement, include terms, conditions or a time limit for the Trust, that contradict the Court's understanding and Judgment of your parent's intentions at the time, they made the Trust.
e) Your father is damaging or jeopardizing the value of your property interest & estate, by mis-use of the property; or the property is subject to immediate loss, due your father's failure to maintain, pay taxes, etc..
f) Why it is unjust, unfair and inequitable for the Court to maintain that your father has a a "life estate" in/to your mother's 50% share of the property, by virtue of the Trust, when title to that 50% share was transferred to your mother, absolutely, pursuant an absolute divorce.
g) Your application for Trust termination, was made for good cause; was made in good faith, was timely made and has merit.
Good luck,
Phroska L. McAlister,ESQ