Legal Question in Tax Law in New York

N.Y. Non-resident Income Tax

I am being audited by N.Y. State for sale of real property there. It was jointly owned and sold in 1998. I have lived in Nevada since 1967.

a. Am I liabel for Income tax in that state?(Does the phrase ''Taxation without representation'' come to mind?)

b.Is not their request for a copy of my 1998 Federal Return an invasion of my privacy.

c.Can they obtain a judgement and lein my property or attach my income? (Soc.Sec. and a pension paid through a NY bank.)

d.Does the State of Nevada allow such collections?


Asked on 4/26/01, 4:27 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Re: N.Y. Non-resident Income Tax

The location of the real property within

the State of New York gives the State In Rem

Jurisdiction and the right to control such

property, including taxing the income (rent)

or gain on sale. An IT-203 Non-Resident

return for 1998 would be required.

In conjunction with the same, a request for your

1998 income tax return is proper since you did

not file the required IT-203.

They can obtain a Judgment and a Lien. However,

Social Security Payments and Pension payments are

generally not subject to attachment for the payment

of the same. (See OJ Simpson who collects a

$ 25000 per month pension which cannot be touched

by the Goldmans)

The State of Nevada would have to recognize and

enforce a valid New York State Judgment under

the Full Faith and Credit Clause.

To further discuss, call 1-716-235-2560

Read more
Answered on 6/18/01, 6:39 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Tax and Taxation Law questions and answers in New York