Legal Question in Credit and Debt Law in North Carolina

I received a civil summons - regarding a vehicle I purchased in 2005. In 2008, I lost my job and my husband who is self employed - lost a lot of his contractors or they cut their prices and their work slowed down considerably due to the economy. Those prices are still cut to this day and the work load for one contractor has not recovered. I did find a job finally - but had to take a huge cut in pay.

I could not afford to pay for the vehicle - so I voluntarily returned the vehicle. The civil summons wants me to pay the difference in the balance of the vehicle and what they sold it for plus attorney fees - totalally around $20,000.00. Which of course I do not have - the most important this to do was to keep my home and roof over my childrens head.

I still do not have the funds to pay that money to them - as we are still struggling to just get by.


Asked on 8/05/10, 5:22 am

2 Answers from Attorneys

Jeff Rosner Rosner Law Firm P.A.

Not sure what your question is. The creditor does have a right to seek the deficiency. You may have certain defenses, work out a settlement, declare bankruptcy, etc . You really need to speak with an attorney to learn about different options and what you need to do to answer the complaint. That complaint must be answered within 30 days or else they will get a default judgment against you really quickly. You also need to be careful how you answer it or they will get a summary judgment against you.

Read more
Answered on 8/10/10, 5:31 am

You will have to decide whether it is best to file bankruptcy or not. There is no wage garnishment in NC. However, judgments last for 10 years and can be renewed for another 10 years. They also earn interest at a rate of 8% per year. The judgment acts as a lien on your real property which means that if you sell it, the creditor will have to be paid out of the sale proceeds, but it depends on how much equity is in the house, whose name is on the deed and whose name the car debt is in.

You should only answer the complaint if one or more of the following are true: (1) the statute of limitations has expired (in NC its 3 years and would start to run from after the car was sold and a demand was made on you for the balance, which you do not share); (2) you already paid; (3) the complaint does not attach certain documents or you have other defenses (like lack of jurisdiction or challenges to venue or service) or the complaint states the wrong amount owed; or (4) you are the victim of identity fraud.

If none of these are true and you owe the debt, then you can answer or do nothing. Either way the creditor will get a judgment against you, whether by default or summary judgment.

Bankruptcy can be filed at any time, although it is somewhat easier if you file before a judgment is entered. I suggest that you not waste time and money fighting the lawsuit if no defenses exist and get a consult with a bankruptcy attorney.

If you want to work out a settlement, you have to have at least 50% of the funds to do a lump sum settlment. Some creditors will want the full balance if you want to make payments. And the payments may be in the neighborhood of 1% to 2% of the debt. If all you can afford is $5 per month, that is not realistic for a $20,000 debt and you are better off filing bankruptcy. If you can afford payments, that will prevent them from trying to execute (collect) on the judgment.

You can make payments directly to the clerk of court after entry of judgment. If you do this, you have to pay at least the monthly interest and something on the principal so that the balance will decrease.

If you just cannot afford it, are judgment proof (which I do not know as I do not know your assets and debts) and if bankruptcy is not an option, then you may just want to do nothing. You will eventually be served with a form called a "notice of rights" and "motion to claim exempt property." Do not ignore this form. It is very important. If you need help, then contact me or another attorney for help in filling it out.

In the meantime, start saving your money, preferably at an online or out of state bank, small community bank or credit union that is 25-50 miles from your house. Do not keep a large amount of money in a bank account at any bank as the creditor will grab it. When you get enough, you can settle the debt at any time.

Read more
Answered on 8/17/10, 1:03 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Credit, Debt and Collections Law questions and answers in North Carolina