Legal Question in Credit and Debt Law in North Carolina
Verbal agreement/contract
Someone loaned money. They insisted nothing in writing, only a verbal agreement. I offered several times to put something in writing but they said no. I have made monthly
payments just like we verbally agreed. Now
6 months later they're trying to get me to sign something that's not the agreement we had (increase dollar amount of monthly payment and less time to pay back) I have not signed anything. Can they sue me, even though
I'm making the payments? Is there anything they can do to me? Is there anything I need to do to protect myself?
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Verbal agreement/contract
I agree 100% with all that Ms. Freiman said and
would have said all that myself.
I'll add a couple of comments: if the interest rate
is the same OR LESS for the new 'proposed' payment schedule
and you can afford the higher payments, consider doing it.
Could there just be a communications gap where the lender is
just asking you to pay it off sooner? How to find out the
interest rate: send me the all the numbers: the amt of the loan,
the monthly payment and number of remaining payments on the original
deal and then what was in the proposed written deal and I'll 'impute'
the rate; you might actually be better off!!!
If you did sign it, there's a strong chance it could never be
enforced, since signing it with today's date, where you are getting nothing for doing so,
lacks contract consideration. But don't sign it. You're right not to sign anything new
now that doesn't comport with your understanding
of the deal.
You understand that higher payments SHOULD get a loan paid
off sooner, and that can be good! Right?
Stuart Williams
Law Offices of Stuart J. Williams
21 Walter St.
Newton, MA
02459-2509
(617) 527-0050
Stuart Williams
Law Offices of Stuart J. Williams
21 Walter St.
Newton, MA
02459-2509
Re: Verbal agreement/contract
A verbal contract is just as valid as aw ritten contract. The problem is to prove what it said.
If the lender sues you, he has the burden to prove the terms of the loan. The fact that you consistently made payments in a certain amount, and the lender accepted those payments without protest, would be some evidence that those were the terms of the loan, and not a higher amount.
I hope you have written receipts for the payments!
There's not much more you can do now - unless you had a witness to the oral agreement. If you haven't got receipts until now, you have two choices:
You can refuse to make payments unless the lender gives you a receipt. That would probably provoke the lender to sue you, and you might not be able to prove any payments.
If you don't want to take that risk, you can be sure to make payments only by check or postal money order, or have a witness.
Good luck!