Legal Question in Employment Law in Ohio

Maternity Leave/Termination

I was scheduled to return to my job after maternity leave last Thursday and I had to call in because my twins had their first shots and were running fevers. When I called in, I was told ''OK, see you tomorrow then.'' Later that day my boss left me a message telling me not to come in the next day because the position was no longer available and that a part time position would best suit me and they didn't have anything available like that for me. I was all set to apply for unemployment UNTIL I get a letter in the mail from them stating the reason for my separation from employment was a voluntary quit...they said that my calling off was an unexcused absence and that I voluntarily quit. I know they are going to argue my application for unemployment, but I should get it don't you think? I saved the message from my answering machine, and if I quit then why would my boss acknowledge my scheduled shift the following morning and tell me not to come in? They filled my position while I was gone and didn't have anywhere to put me because I'm sure they were counting on me not returning from maternity leave.


Asked on 8/23/05, 5:00 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Eileen Joyce Baughman & Joyce LLC

Re: Maternity Leave/Termination

While you question your entitlement to unemployment benefits, my first concern, after reading your post, is whether your employer violated the Family and Medical Leave Act (�FMLA�) and/or the Pregnancy Discrimination Act (�PDA�) (in addition to applicable Ohio law). Under the FMLA, IF: (1) you had been employed by that employer for at least 12 months; (2) had worked at least 1250 hours during the 12 month period preceding your leave; and (3) your employer has 50 or more employees, you were entitled to 12 weeks of leave (in a 12 month period). If these criteria are met, your employer was required to hold your position open for you.

Under the PDA (applies to employers with 15 or more employees), your employer is required to hold open your position for the same length of time it holds positions open for other employees on sick or disability leave. In other words, the PDA precludes your employer from treating your temporary disability (i.e., pregnancy) differently than it treats other employee disabilities.

If your maternity leave, plus the extra day called off exceeds 12 weeks, then your employer may have had cause to terminate you. Whether that is the case however depends on your employer�s leave policy and if/how it designated any or all of your leave.

As for the unemployment, file a claim as soon as possible because it will not relate back to the date of termination. If your employer disputes the claim on the basis of your alleged voluntary resignation, so be it. You will have an opportunity to provide your side of the story (a forced resignation is the legal equivalent of a termination). If the claim is denied, you will have an opportunity to appeal the decision. Be sure to read everything you receive from the ODJFS very carefully. The documents the ODJFS provides typically provide strict (and short) deadlines relative to the claim/appeal process. Finally, keep a copy of the voice mail referenced in your post.

If you have any additional questions or want clarification based on additional information you can provide as indicated above, feel free to email me at [email protected].

Read more
Answered on 8/23/05, 10:04 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Labor and Employment Law questions and answers in Ohio