Legal Question in Civil Rights Law in Oklahoma

Home Security Cameras

Recently, I installed security cameras on the exterior of my home. We've had evidence of 3 break-in attempts (We don't know who it was, but we suspect our neighbor), and I was assaulted by my neighbor in September. He will be arraigned for misdemeanor assault charges next week.

This same neighbor has now had an attorney send us a letter demanding that our cameras be taken down because they claim we are impeding the sale of their home. (The cameras are about the size of a tennis ball. They're dark gray and sit against dark brown trim. They're barely visible to the casual observer.)

They also claim we are invading their privacy. While their exterior is visible in two of the shots, none of their windows are visible.

I've checked with the local police and have been assured that we have not broken any city or state laws.

I don't want to remove my cameras because I have a wife and 4 young children. I'm concerned for their safey, but I can't afford to fight this right now. Money is tight.

Do they have a case? Do I really need to hire an attorney?

What realistically might happen if I call their bluff and ignore the letter?


Asked on 11/20/07, 10:50 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys
Marsha Dixon

Re: Home Security Cameras

No. They do not have a case. As the police stated, you have not broken any laws and you are not violating their privacy, particularly, if you have historical and documented cause to protect the health, safety and welfare of your family.

However, in the meantime, it is important that you carefully document any actions or activities surrounding these illegal incidents or confrontations with your neighbor, i.e., court documents and police reports. This information will further justify the need to use the camera's.

Read more
Answered on 11/25/07, 6:12 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Civil Rights Law questions and answers in Oklahoma