Legal Question in Medical Malpractice in Oregon

Unsuccessful Surgery...What Now?

Endoscopic surgery was perfomed on my L5 (back) Jan.7

Immediately after the proceedure, I still felt the siatic nerve pain down my right leg and numbness in the right foot (same symptoms as pre-surgery). The symptoms, however, are not noticeably worse than before surgery. It is now April 27 and I still have the same pain in right leg and numbness in right foot due to siatica. I have tried physical therapy and traction as the surgeon recommended (with no luck). Surgeon prescribed Celebrex (anti-inflamitory) which has seemed to work ok in reducing the pain. I started on the Celebrex last month. Do I have legal grounds to sue the surgeon (since the proceedure didn't work), or am I out of luck since I signed waivers that basically state that "there is no guarantee that surgery will work" ? Thanks!


Asked on 4/27/00, 10:44 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Sam Hochberg Sam Hochberg & Associates

Re: Unsuccessful Surgery...What Now?

First off, was the procedure done by any state agency, such as OHSU? If so, there is a 180-Day "Tort Claim Notice," which means you must give a special form of notice to the government agency within 180 days you reasonably discoverd or should have discovered the negligence. There is also a TWO-YEAR statute of limitations on the claim itself, regardless of who the defendant is.

As to the heart of the matter: You'll need to have a lawyer hire a doctor to review your doctor's chart notes. In order to proceed, you really ought to have a doctor willing to testify that the work your doctor performed fell below the standard of care for similar doctors. Your damages may not be significant, however, since your condition is unchanged. Unless the doc somehow made an error below the standard of care AND it is one which messed up the ability of some other doc to fix it LATER, it sound like a very tough row to hoe for you.

Also, the mere fact that the surgery didn't work doesn't mean that you have a case. Medicine is not an exact science. The failure of the doctor to succeed must be more than mere error: It must be an error that would not happen but for an action (or inaction)which falls below the standard of care for similar doctors. Hope that helps you.

Read more
Answered on 6/12/00, 4:45 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Medical Malpractice Law questions and answers in Oregon