Legal Question in Consumer Law in Pennsylvania

Invention scam

Last June I paid a company $700 to pursue an idea/invention. The company appeared legit stating numerous successful clients. They promised a patent search/product search that could only be done by a patent attorney (well done). They also promised to submit a declaration to the patent office. I received a book of research, all of which I could have done over the internet, and NO documents indicating whether or not any decleration was submitted to the patent office. My numerous phone calls have not been returned (unlike when they wanted my business. At that time they wouldn't stop calling). I have since then located other information concerning them. It appears they are not reputable and have cheated others out of hundreds of thousands if not millions. They are a big company with thousands of clients (unfortunates such as myself). Is there any recourse that I can take?


Asked on 10/04/05, 11:53 am

2 Answers from Attorneys
Daniel Harrison Berger Harrison, APC

Re: Invention scam

Your recorse depends on what was represented to you. Did you sign a contract?

Read more
Answered on 10/07/05, 8:02 pm
William Marvin Cohen, Placitella & Roth, P.C.

Re: Invention scam

Yep, it's an invention scam. There's a number of businesses which prey on people in this way, low-end model agencies that charge bundles for "photos", loan brokers, those guys trying to smuggle ill-gotten millions out of Nigeria.

Other than being a cautionary tale, a practical remedy is difficult, and that's what the scammers count on. I'm sure you wish you had done the internet research before giving them your money, so you don't need me telling you that.

I do some consumer work, including class actions. Generally the scam artists hide their money pretty well, and obviously $700 isn't going to cover the legal costs even if you could collect a refund.

Class actions are a possibility, but it's tough to bring them where each person may get different promises. Typically, there may be a contract you signed that tries to limit your rights in the fine print.

So your best bet may be a complaint with the state consumer protection office. They may intervene to try to get a refund, and if they see a pattern of complaints, might prosecute. Doesn't cost you anything and won't hurt to try.

Read more
Answered on 10/04/05, 12:24 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Consumer Law questions and answers in Pennsylvania