Legal Question in Civil Litigation in Pennsylvania

civil lawsuits

In Pa. if a member of a non-profit volunteer fire department files a civil law suit against the department, can he remain a member in good standing without losing any of his rights during the suit, also if he sues an individual officer can he remain a member in good standing. my department is real close to having a discrimination suit filed against it and i believe as a scare tactic it has been mentioned to this member that he will lose his rights as a member if he should file suit. I wsa wondering if this was true ?


Asked on 11/29/00, 7:07 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

William Marvin Cohen, Placitella & Roth, P.C.

Re: civil lawsuits

I'd go a little farther than Mark. You should consult an attorney NOW. I don't specialize in discrimination, but my instinct is that if a member is making a discrimination claim, any type of adverse action could backfire and be a really stupid thing to do, because of how it looks.

Most discrimination laws had anti-retaliation provisions, and given that threats already have been made, apparently in direct response to the member's claim "as a scare tactic", it would be quite difficult to show a legitimate reason for acting against him.

Read more
Answered on 12/04/00, 8:58 am
Marc Bragg Bialecki & Bragg, PC

Re: civil lawsuits

Certainly not a pleasant position to be in.

Your question assumes there is no "other" reason

to remove the "good standing" designation. A Retaliation

charge for picking on one that has filed a civil suit based on discrimination

is generally a sufficient safeguard against employer

retaliation. . . but not always.

Please feel free to call. 610-444-7508 to discuss

further.

http://www.chescolawyers.com/BB

Read more
Answered on 12/03/00, 7:38 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More General Civil Litigation questions and answers in Pennsylvania