Legal Question in Employment Law in Pennsylvania
commission based pay for auto techs
I work in an automotive dealership and am earning my pay based on flat-rate commission(ie. replace waterpump-2 hours labor). I earn $25 per flat-rate hour. Recently, the service manager changed the pay scale to ''skill levels'', A-120% of flat-rate, B-100%, and C-75% of my flat-rate amount. I have been given no notification prior to this change, nor have I been given a list of the jobs in each ''skill-level''. Is it legal for my boss to adjust my pay in this manner, for most of the work is C-work according to my flag sheets? Also, today I was informed that the labor times we used to charge are no longer correct, and now the labor times are out of Chilton's... again with no prior notification. I have 24 years experience as an automotive technician and am very productive, working extra days (weekends) to reach a goal and now this happens, do I have any options other than finding another job?
1 Answer from Attorneys
Re: commission based pay for auto techs
You asked about a change in pay rate.
This doesn't create an actionable issue with regard to pay as long as the company pays you equal to or greater than that required under the applicable laws (such as minimum wage, overtime, etc.).
You would be left to negotiate with the employer. If you are that productive then they would sore to lose you. Also, the allocation of work would have to be specifically metered across the board. Is there any unlawful discriminatory intent or effect of the policy change.
My suggestion is to live with this a short while and watch for any discriminatory intent or effect. This would be where higher paying work was funneled to workers on any basis other than random (such as age or even production rate).
Now the sticky part. According to recent rulings, you only have six months from the time the discriminatory action accrues to make a claim of discrimination, so you need to look at this in a compressed time frame.
I have my theories about this. But I would definitely like to hear what the results of your observations are. Keep accurate records and see if you can get a feel for what the other workers are seeing. Don't do any investigation, just keep your eyes and ears tuned. Contact me or another attorney to follow up on this matter well within the six month time frame.
Regards,
Roger