Legal Question in Product Liability in Pennsylvania

Re: we sold a stolen dirtbike,unknowingly

You asked about your liability where you bought and sold a stolen dirtbike.

The law isn't crystal clear on this area. But it is clear enough to advise. No, as long as you had no knowledge that the vehicle was stolen then you likely can't be compelled to refund the buyer's money.

On the other hand, if the buyer can _prove_ that you knew it was stolen or should have known that it was stolen, then they may be able to collect. But they would also have to show that they did not have the same level of knowledge, or why not.

Generally you are what is known as an bona fide purchaser for value. As was the subsequent purchaser. Think of it like a game of musical chairs. The person caught with the bike when the music stops is the loser.

The law does this to prevent the situation that you described (suing back through the chain of custody). In any eventuality then there will likley be a loser unless you can come back to a culpable party. It may as well be the one at the tail end who likely also is taking the smallest hit (depreciation) and where it is easiest to place. It may help to think of it the other way, if there was a reward of $2,000 for return of the bike would they give the additional $500 to you?

Regards,