Legal Question in Real Estate Law in Pennsylvania

If I take my landlord to small claims court for failure to return security depos

If my lease on my apt was up in 4/99 and I was allowed to stay till 9/99 without a lease, does the terms of the lease still exist? If my landlord did a walk through when I was leaving and did not find a problem can she come up with a list of damages, that if were accurate would have been visible on the walk through, which she approved. Do I have to prove the damages were normal wear and tear, or does she have to prove there were real damages. Example a build of lint in the dryer hose. What is required of both of us in a small claims court?


Asked on 1/08/00, 8:22 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Gerald Hershenson Law Office of Gerald M. Hershenson

Re: If I take my landlord to small claims court for failure to return security d

You intially have the burden to prove that the security deposit was not received. Then the burden shifts to the Landlord to substantiate the reason he did not return the security deposit. The lease must be reviewed by a qualified attorney in order to properly advise as to whether the continuation of the lease was month to month or whether the lease was automatically renewed for the period of the original lease. Under Pennsylvania law the Landlord is required to return the security deposit within thirty day of the lease termination and give notice to his tenant in writing as to any damages suffered and deducted from the deposit. A failure to provide such notice or reason of the refusal to return the deposit subjects the Landlord to liability for double the amount of security deposit. The fact the Landlord did not inform you of any damages at the time of inspection will work against him if you have witnessess to substantiate the inspection. The notice within thirty days of the damages is a key element that should not be overlooked. Suggest you consult legal counsel in your local area.

Read more
Answered on 1/17/00, 2:57 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Real Estate and Real Property questions and answers in Pennsylvania