Legal Question in Wills and Trusts in Pennsylvania

My father and brother passed away in 2010 with his girlfriend of 3 years shortly afterwards. They had no assets together as far as I am aware. My father had a very small insurance policy left only to his girlfriend. She was never issued due to the timing of her death. The girlfriend had no other family except a distant cousin who did not even bother to obtain her ashes. She blankly stated she wanted nothing to do with her death. Her close neighbors got involved and would not allow my family to enter the home to obtain the rest of my father's belongings. As a year shortly passes, I am trying to properly handle this matter. I have obtained the Renunciation form for both my dad's girlfriend and her deceased mother since the home is in her name. I recently found out that as administrator of the estate I am only entitled to 5% of each estate: house and life insurance. I am very disappointed with this whole matter because a) I do not even know what is left in the home since it has been 11 months with the neighbors have full access and b) the total of the 5% would not even be one month's salary for me. I was hoping to receive the whole policy to help cover my father and brother's funeral. My family was unable to obtain his girlfriend's ashes until no one claimed it 8 months later. The distant cousin and her did not talk over 30 years. She stated multiple times that she had no family but us as well as she would burn the home before giving it to her cousin. After my father's death, she told me she was going to use some of the money to transfer the home into her name and leave it to my siblings and I. My question is: Is it legal to obtain a letter from the cousin saying with the renunciation forms she does not wish to receive any of the assets and they would be transferred over to me? Can I purchase a plot for the girlfriend with her assets before anything is distributed out? Can I make donations to charities that I know she felt passionately about? With the Renunciation form, without being sworn in yet, can I access the home to see if anything is left? If I do not want to move forward, what happens?


Asked on 6/24/11, 12:15 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

You have raised separate issues. The insurance policy is a non-probate asset ordinarily. What this means is that the benefits go directly to the beneficary named on the policy, not to your father's estate. It was up to your father to name some kind of contingent beneficiary. You do not indicate the timespan between your father's death and the girlfriend's death; you will have to read the policy as I don't know if there is any type of length of time for survivorship in order for a beneficiary to receive the proceeds.

If there is, then the girlfriend would have to survive the required length of time in order to receive the benefits. If she did not meet the requirements. the proceeds would be paid to your father's estate as no contingent beneficiary was named. If there is no survivorship requirement or the girlfriend met the requirements, then the benefits on the policy would be paid to the estate of the girlfriend. The insurance proceeds would be distributed as per her will or, if none, then via the state intestacy laws. If she did not want her assets to pass to distant relatives then she needed to do some estate planning by making a will or trust.

I assume that you have obtained the renunciation form for the estate of the girlfriend and, if you are the administrator, then the girlfriend did not have a will at all.

I do not know why you allowed the neighbors to interfere. First, when your father died, you should have arranged to get your father's possessions. Second, when the girlfriend died, the neighbors had NO authority to do anything and if they were somehow obstructing you, you should have obtained a lawyer, if necessary, and obtained access to the home to retrieve your father's possessions. You should have been appointed as the personal representative of your father's estate to accomplish this purpose.

What you propose is not permissible as you have outlined. If the cousin renounces her right to receive assets, then the assets will not pass to you but to the next of kin, if any. At some point, state law provides a cutoff point beyond which heirs cannot inherit and the estate of the deceased person goes to the state.

However, the cousin can receive her share, which will be whatever is left AFTER the estate is administered and bills are paid. The cousin then can make a gift to you in whatever sum he/she chooses. The cousin can gift up to $13,000 per year free of gift tax.

You ask if you can purchase a burial plot. I do not understand why as you state that the girlfriend was cremated. Do you mean a place to keep her ashes? Funeral/burial expenses are the responsbility of the estate. If there is not enough money, these are among the items that are paid first. You can only use the insurance funds for the girlfriend's funeral expenses but not your father's and brother's funerals.

Regardless of what the girlfriend said she would do, the fact remains that she did not do this and unless you have some kind of written agreement with the girlfriend or unless she made a valid will leaving the home to you and your siblings, then the home will be distributed as per her will (if any) or as per state intestacy law.

You can do what you want with any money that you have in the name of the girlfriend. However, unless the girlfriend made a will leaving money to charities or to be dispersed to charity at her personal representative's discretion, then you cannot use funds of the girlfriend's estate for this purpose. It doesn't matter how much the girlfriend hated her cousin. If she felt that strongly, she would have bothered to make a will or trust.

You cannot do anything UNTIL you are officially appointed by the court as the personal representative (called an administrator if there is no will or executor if there is a will).

Depending on how much money will be in the estate, it may be wise for you to retain the assistance of counsel to help you with the process. However, you should speak to the probate court first to see if that will be necessary.

If you do not administer the girlfriend's estate it will be up to her heirs to do so. I don't see that it is any of your concern other than to make sure that you get something out of it. If you want to access the home, the person who is the personal representative of your father's estate would have the authority to do that but would have to get permission from the personal representative of the girlfriend's estate. From that standpoint, it may be simpler if you were to handle the girlfriend's estate as you can then access her home, take an inventory of what she owned and remove any items belonging to your father.

The commission allowed is what it is - its not a flat 5% but it is graduated depending on the size and complexity of the estate. If it will not be enough to compensate you for all the aggravation, then don't do it. People serve as personal representatives, not because of the commission, but because it is necessary to wind up the affairs of the deceased person in an orderly manner. Usually, this task is performed by loved ones who have a vested interest in seeing that the assets are transferred from the dead person to the dead person's heirs properly. However, if you don't want to do it, there may be someone (an attorney in town) that the court can recommend.

Read more
Answered on 6/24/11, 3:10 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Probate, Trusts, Wills & Estates questions and answers in Pennsylvania