Legal Question in Real Estate Law in Rhode Island
Tree on property line.
There is a large tree on my land, close to my property line. A portion of the tree hangs over a neighbors property. The neighbor wants to cut off the portion over his property and I will not give consent. The tree has an unconventional shape; thus fully a 3rd hangs over his property 20+ feet up.
The neighbor reports that he is going to cut the tree, with or without my consent. He believes that it is his right. I contend that it is my tree, on my property.
What are my rights?
The property is the city of Providence.
1 Answer from Attorneys
Re: Tree on property line.
Your neighbor does have a common law right to trim back any trees that overhang his property. This right was re-affirmed in a 1975 case by the name of Rosa v. Oliveira. In that case the RI Supreme Court in upholding the action by the landowner who cut the neighbor's tree stated:
"In taking such action, she was exercising her common-law right as a
landowner to cut off the limbs which were overhanging or encroaching
on her property from trees located on the adjoining property"
As to whether your neighbor can compel you to cut the tree back that is a much more difficult question. The neighbor could sue for "equitable relief" which would be an injunction ordering you to cut back the tree. This may however be a costly and time-consuming method costing far in excess of the cost of just cutting the tree.
Finally, over the years I have been paid a lot of money to preside over neighbor wars and even I think it is a tremendous waste of money. Unless you are planning on moving in the near future, I would be very careful about getting into an unnecessary fight.
I hope this is helpful, if not please feel free to call.
Jules J. D'Alessandro, Esq.
D'Alessandro Law Associates, Inc.
1515 Smith Street
No. Providence, RI 02911
Tel: (401) 353-0440
Fax: (401) 353-0344
E-Mail: [email protected]
Web: www.dlawinc.com
The information given in this E-mail is for information purposes only. Our giving you information is not legal advice and should not be relied upon for anything other than discussion purposes only. Our giving you legal information does not create an attorney client relationship, which relationship does not exist unless and until a retainer or engagement agreement is signed by and between you and this law firm.