Legal Question in Family Law in Texas
Mediation vs Divorce Court and cost of lawyers
In January our SIL managed to put a hysterical spin on some everyday issues and won temporary custory of our four grandchildren by supposedly proving our daughter to be dangerous even though he has left them with her 95% of the time since then and has tried to reconcile twice. She has no family or support in TX but he wants to keep her there. Her lawyer was not good in Court, he is counselling her to mediate ie The kids for her agreement to stay in TX which is what the husband wanted when he filed to begin with. Also there was no de Nova hearing to refute the lies told in Court and now he doesn't want the personal evaluations he requested to begin with. They already owe lawyers $25000.00 and she does not have the money to change. If they mediate will the Jan decision be an albatross around her neck? Should she fight to vindicate herself with a passive lawyer? Is there any chance she can move to be near her loved ones later if she mediates now by agreeing to stay in TX? If he gets nasty later and takes her back to Court can he dredge up the Jan 2006 decision and use it against her? He is charismatic and can be very persuasive; she has been a stay at home Mom
My faith in the system has hit rock bottom. Some encouragement please ...
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Mediation vs Divorce Court and cost of lawyers
First of all, it is extremely difficult to assess a child custody case with so little information provided.
Know that ALL child custody cases are very emotional and very complicated.
There could be many legal explanations for the result of the recent contested hearing. They may be legal reasons that your daughter is too upset to understand. It is even more difficult for you to clearly assess the situation from long-distance.
Mediation is required by judges in the counties I practice, prior to setting a case for final trial.
Many, many times a party participated in mediation, convinced that it would be pointless, when in fact, both parties gave a little (or a lot), and were able to reach an agreement.
It is rarely a waste of time, inasmuch, at least the attorneys learn more about the other side's positions, and are better prepared for trial.
Since everyone has so much invested in this case at this point, it is a good idea to first see if this attorney-client relationship can be rescued. If not, at least leave on good terms, so that there is cooperation with the new counsel.
Re: Mediation vs Divorce Court and cost of lawyers
You obviously favor your daughter.
However, the courts assume that each person is a normal, reasonable person until proven otherwise.
Additionally, she married him and had children with him. If he was such a bad person, then why did she stay with him.
You have only heard one side of the story. In divorce there are at least 2 sides and usually there is at least one other side to every story.
Your grandchildren are Texas residents. Your daughter is free to leave the state and leave wherever she wants. However, the children are going to remain in Texas.
It is the policy of the State of Texas for children to leave near both parents. It is NOT in the best interests of the children to be uprooted and removed from their schools, friends, and other parent.
Additionally, mediation is required in the State of Texas.
You can go to the Houston Bar Associaton website -- I believe it's www.hba.org and read a free pamphlet on-line under family law.
Lastly, it is both parents obligation to support their children. Whoever gets custody will get child support from the other parent. For example, if the father gets custody, the mother will have to pay him child support based on her income. If she does not work, then minumum wage child support will be ordered.