Legal Question in Insurance Law in Texas

I'm a P&C Insurance agent that a client has filed a lawsuit against me. The company has already paid him $300,000 and he states its not enough to replace his loss. He had previously sued me but I never heard anything anymore because what they had written was also lies he was saying and it showed on the papers. I have read the new documents and all that he states is lies also. I have E&O but I want to know if I can sue him and if so what is the legal description of my suit to him. Also can I choose my own attorney or do I have to use one that my E&O company hires for me?


Asked on 12/22/09, 1:45 pm

1 Answer from Attorneys

Heather Kubiak The Kubiak Law Firm PLLC

From your question, I assume the following:

Your client sued you and the insurer, and the company settled with the client for $300,000. Now, the suit is just pending against you. The case against you is false and brought just for the purpose of "getting more money" because the insurer did not pay your client enough in settlement.

You have Errors and Omissions insurance.

First, you need to notify your insurance carrier and let them know about the suit. Some policies allow you to choose your own attorney, some require you to accept the attorney of the insurer's choosing, and some policies provide a list of panel counsel - that is, counsel that is pre-approved by the insurer. The approved counsel list is usually attached to the policy as an exhibit to the policy. You will need to look at the defense provisions to determine whether you have the right to choose your counsel.

It is best to discuss a counterclaim with the attorney you ultimately hire. If the client sued you for the Texas Deceptive Practices Act, you can make a counterclaim for groundless suit, and ask for your attorneys' fees. Also, under Texas law, an attorney must believe that the claims made against a defendant are made in good faith, otherwise there could be sanctions. (I warn you, however, that this is very rare).

There are other counterclaims that may be appropriate - slander, libel, and business disparagement - but these should be discussed with your attorney.

Good luck!

Read more
Answered on 12/29/09, 5:51 am


Related Questions & Answers

More Insurance Law questions and answers in Texas