Legal Question in Family Law in Washington

Emergency Temporary Custody

We are grandparents with Emergency Temporary Custody of our 20 month old grandson, recently evaluated as a ''Special Ed. student'' and in a program, and seeing a Child Therapist too. A G.A.L. has been appointed who told us that as grandparents we have no rights. We must prove our daughter is unfit or grandson will be returned to mother. She does not live near us and this was not a Child Protective Service intervention. A ''Settlement Hearing'' is scheduled for January 2004. The Commisssioner said he doesn't want this case dragging on in his court and instructed our daughter to file to regain custody. This could happen before Settlement Hearing and therapy to find out why grandson bangs his head on wall. (1) IF this happens, how can we keep grandchild with us while we appeal his decision? (2) How can we get a Judge to hear our case instead of a Commissioner?


Asked on 10/26/03, 1:37 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

Gary Preble Preble Law Firm, P.S.

Re: Emergency Temporary Custody

1. You do not have the choice of a judge rather than a commissioner in the preliminary motions prior to trial, although any decision of the commissioner may be reviewed by a judge by what is called a motion to revise. See RCW 2.24.050 at http://www.leg.wa.gov/RCW/index.cfm?fuseaction=section§ion=2.24.050

2. The GAL was only partly correct. Grandparents have no rights in most cases to VISITATION (after the Custody of Smith case decided in the US Supreme Court under the name of Troxell v. Granville). However when CUSTODY is in issue, there is a two-part test, either prong of which may be proved.

The first is as the GAL stated-- that you prove the parent (your child in this case) unfit. Normally I don't prefer this route because the grandparent usually wants to protect the grandchild with as little harm to their relationship with their own child as possible.

The second prong you could prove is that placement of the child with an otherwise fit parent would have a detrimental effect on the development of the child.

As to your present Temporary Custody, I presume you have already filed a Non-Parental custody action. I would recommend that you get an attorney if your daughter is going to fight and especially if the GAL is not favorable toward you or your chances.

Read more
Answered on 10/26/03, 5:45 pm
Jahnis Abelite ABELITE LAW OFFICES, P.S.

Re: Emergency Temporary Custody

This is a very serious and complicated matter that requires the use of an experienced family law attorney who has worked in custody cases before. There is no reasonable manner of getting this matter sorted out for you on a BBS system like this. The simple answer to your questions is this: There is no simple answer and you must see an attorney IMMEDIATELY if you wish to retain at least temporary custody of your grandson.

Read more
Answered on 10/26/03, 1:46 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Family Law, Divorce, Child Custody and Adoption questions and answers in Washington