Legal Question in Intellectual Property in Wisconsin
Uploading and selling music
What it be legal if I uploaded music from a CD that I purchased, legally and at full price, on to my PC and then sold the CD to a used CD store?
Asked on 12/27/03, 9:29 pm
1 Answer from Attorneys
Lawrence Graves
Coolidge & Graves PLLC
Re: Uploading and selling music
This is technically wrong but in practice there is nothing that the copyright owner is going to be able to do about it: music CDs do not require any kind of registration to load, and the second-hand CD store likely does not require identification when it buys used CDs, so nothing ties the initial purchaser to the CD in the stream of commerce.
Best wishes,
LDWG
Answered on 12/29/03, 10:24 am