Legal Question in Real Estate Law in Wisconsin
Enchroachment
I live on a small lot - 40'wide. our driveway enchroaches on the neighbors property. the asphalt is up to the side of his garage and has been that way for over 20 years. He now wants the asphalt removed and wants us to pay for supposed damage done to his garage walls and floor from water he says is leaking into his garage. We know from previous owners that this garage has been there and the floor was already cracked. What is our responsibility for this? Can we ask for an easement since it has been son long?
1 Answer from Attorneys
Enchroachment, Adverse Possession and Damages
It is sometimes possible to win a claim for adverse possession in WI after a sufficient amount of time has passed in an encroachment situation. However, there are numerous legal requirements which must first be satisfied. These include, among other things, that the adverse occupation of the land was continuous, hostile, and "open and notorious" for a long period of time. These terms are defined in hundreds of case opinions issued by the Supreme Court and Court of Appeals over the last two centuries. The judge or jury will make the final decision after a trial, unless the parties are able to resolve the case via a settlement or via an alternate dispute resolution process (such as arbitration or mediation). This is generally expensive litigation since it is "fact intensive," meaning that cases can be won or lost based upon a large number of variables in the land's history. It is also sometimes possible to win an easement by proscriptive use in some situations short of adverse possession. Finally, winning parties can sometimes recover damages caused by the losing party.