Legal Question in Civil Rights Law in Virginia

my legal rights as a shopper

Do I have any at all? A book shop owner (Chop Suey Books) made me relinquish my purse if I wanted to shop there. He said he demanded all purses big enoufh to hold a book. Is it legal? Is it ethical? I dont mind checking my bags but my purse. No. The owner says he does not know why I am reluctant to do this or why I consider it a privacy issue. I can't believe he would ask for my purse. I can't believe it's legal. He says he could demand anything of me if I want to come in his shop. Could a jewelry store demand to keep my wallet because a diamond ring would fit into my wallet? I am flummoxed and absolutely furious about this.


Asked on 4/28/07, 3:22 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

Michael Hendrickson Law Office Michael E. Hendrickson

Re: my legal rights as a shopper

As far as I can can tell, your question involves first and foremost the applicable laws of the Commonwealth

of Virginia, and, not, whatever the applicable laws of the state of Washington might be with respect to this situation---nor do I believe that there are any credible questions presented for adjudication by federal courts.

In my opinion, the owner's interpretation (which you've dewscribed)of what he believes he can legally get away with regarding to checking your purse and related parcels under the applicable laws of the Commonwealth, is probably about right. Does this mean that's it moral or necessarily acceptable? Not hardly. However, we're discussing the Commonwealth of Virgina and not the assertedly "more progressive jurisdiction" of Washington state.

Read more
Answered on 4/28/07, 11:40 pm
Regina Mullen Legal Data Services, PLC

Re: my legal rights as a shopper

That's a very good question. Practically speaking, no he cannot demand "anything" of you just for the "privilege" of shopping in his shop.

Until men start carrying purses, it IS discriminatory against women.

The suggestion is to write a letter to the editor, contact the BBB in your area and the state consumer advocacy board to see what the legal rules are specifically. One thing is certain: his control is not absolute.

On the other hand, why shop there [read: give him your time or money] if the terms of service are so awful.

Read more
Answered on 4/28/07, 4:07 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Civil Rights Law questions and answers in Virginia