Legal Question in Business Law in California

Implications of leaving an S-Corp as a partner?

Hi there.

I am a 15% shareholder in a small (5 person) S-Corp. If I want to leave the company and forfeit my shares, are there any legal implications of doing so? Is it just a matter of saying, ''I am out of here'', or is a more formal process to go through?

One of our founders put in all of the money for this startup, but we haven't made any money.

Thanks for the help.


Asked on 2/07/08, 8:16 pm

2 Answers from Attorneys

Bryan Whipple Bryan R. R. Whipple, Attorney at Law

Re: Implications of leaving an S-Corp as a partner?

Shareholders in corporations aren't partners. Partners can withdraw from a partnership. Shareholders cannot (and need not) dissociate themselves in the same way.

You can indeed just say, "I'm outta here!" and if you put it in writing with a bit more formality and hand it to the president or secretary of the corporation (perhaps with a few more details!) you can effectively resign as a director (if you were one) and/or as an officer (if you were one).

However, you'll remain a shareholder. There is no way I know of to forfeit your shares in a corporation, nor to force the corporation or any other shareholder to buy them back, or accept them back as a gift. They kinda stick to you. This becomes a particular problem when you'd like to be rid of them to establish a tax loss to get the writeoff. Of course, if you paid nothing for them in the first place, you'd have a zero basis and no loss would be possible. I have had the same problem personally, holding small business shares that no one wanted and thus I couldn't establish a loss by dumping them at 1c on the dollar.

Corporations sometimes have buy-sell agreements where a withdrawing owner can oblige the company to but his shares, or vice-versa and company can require the departing holder to sell back the shares, but I'd guess this corporation or its co-promoters have no such arrangement.

There are four other shareholders; my suggestion would be, if nothing compels you to sell them in any particular way or to any particular person, to offer your 15% stake (the shares) to whichever of the other four will give you the highest price - or any price - just to be rid of them.

Since it's an "S" corp. be sure they give you K-1 forms for your tax return, and talk to your tax preparer about your capital gain or loss and any flow-through benefit you get from the corporation's losses.

Read more
Answered on 2/07/08, 9:06 pm
Terry A. Nelson Nelson & Lawless

Re: Implications of leaving an S-Corp as a partner?

talk to your tax man about the consequences. Legally, just ensure proper documentation of the stock transfer back to the company.

Read more
Answered on 2/08/08, 1:00 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Business Law questions and answers in California