Legal Question in Construction Law in California

is it worth suing

I hired a licensed and bonded concrete company to redo my driveway, walkways around the house, and the back patio last October. They did a lousy job and did not finish everything that was stated on the contract. I've contacted the CSLB, and they told me they will revolk their license due to numberous claims against this company. I've also contacted the bond compay and currently there are 3 claims against the $10K bond. My out of pocket loss is over $12K, my portion of the bond is $2600, the estimate for the bad concrete job is $30K, but I did not get a quote for the unfinished work yet. I know that I have a good case, but is it worth suing? Will the attorney fees eat up all of the money? I can't afford to hire a lawyer if I have to pay by the hour. I would like a case where it could be on contingency, but still enough left over for me to reclaim my losses. Is this plausible? Is it worth suing? Thank you.


Asked on 8/28/06, 5:11 pm

3 Answers from Attorneys

H.M. Torrey The Law Offices of H.M. Torrey

Re: is it worth suing

Anything is "plausible" and you do have a good case, especially if the company at issue can be readily located, collected against and in jurisdiction. Our Law Firm may be able to give you prompt, affordable legal assistance in this most unfortunate matter. Contact us today for a free phone consultation.

Read more
Answered on 8/28/06, 6:03 pm
Gary Redenbacher Redenbacher & Brown, LLP

Re: is it worth suing

If there are presently 3 claims against the license bond, you've likely located a deadbeat contractor. My experience is that these contractors live hand to mouth and once the license bond is exhausted, there's very little to collect from. They get jobs by sending out a low bid, collecting as much as possible up front and then abandoning the job while they still have most of the money in their pocket.

Finding a lawyer to do contingency work on a breach of contract action is pretty tough. It should be well nigh impossible if there's no obvious source of funds with which to collect. Unfortunately, contingency cases are largely restricted to personal injury lawyers where there's an insurance carrier to fund the win and the upside to winning can be enormous. I've seen inexperienced lawyers take contract cases on contingency in the hope of getting established, but that's about it. A few lawyers will work on a flat fee. For example, many of my colleagues doing criminal defense work will perform certain tasks for a set fee. The rest of the lawyers in the country (and this is the vast majority) work by the hour.

What you might want to do is bring an action in small claims court after you get your payment from the license bond. The jurisdictional amount went up to $7500 this past year. The paperwork is very easy and the judges tend to be very sympathetic to homeowners. Look up nolo.com for a very well written book on how to win in small claims court. Of course, you will still have the problem of how to collect from the guy once you get your judgment. Nolo has a book on this, too, but don't get your hopes up.

Read more
Answered on 8/28/06, 7:00 pm
Terry A. Nelson Nelson & Lawless

Re: is it worth suing

Sorry, but you're dreaming. An attorney with an office and overhead to pay for will look first to see if the debtor has reachable assets before taking such case at all, and then probably would do so only on hourly basis. The contractor ripped you off, along with others, and will likely disappear to start under a new name. Even if you traced him down, he won't have anything to pay you or your attorney with. At best, go after him in small claims, or contact a local law school to see if students will help you as part of a 'clinic' or legal aid office.

Read more
Answered on 8/28/06, 8:09 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Construction Law questions and answers in California