Legal Question in Criminal Law in California
My father was accused of a crime and then was tricked into going to police station under false pretenses to be interrogated and when he arrived at the police station he was immediately led into an interrogation room and interrogated by 2 police officers and prior to the interrogation he was never read the Miranda warning/rights. He was cohered into giving the officers self incriminating information. My father has never been arrested and did not know his rights at all and after the interrogation he was handcuffed and arrested and at which time he was finely read his Miranda rights. What proof is required by police to prove that a suspect was read his Miranda rights and understood them? And doesn�t a waiver have to signed by the suspect if he waves his rights prior to a custodian interrogation . how can he prove his rights were violated.
2 Answers from Attorneys
Written Miranda waivers are not required.
You have obviously done some research. As you know, Miranda warnings are only required during custodial interrogations.
Your father was only arrested at the end of the questioning. If he was not in custody, no warning was required. The courts will look at all of the circumstances to determine whether he was confined under conditions equivalent to a formal arrest.
Cops often lie to a suspect, saying they will not arrest him, to avoid triggering an obligation to give a Miranda warning. The US Supreme Court says it's legal.
That's one of the reasons criminal defense attorneys tell people NEVER to talk to the cops.
It is already too late to tell him to exercise his 5th Amendment rights to SHUT UP and call a lawyer, as every cop show on TV correctly teaches. His attorney will now have to make any motions to dismiss or suppress evidence that may be appropriate, and defend the charges in court hearings and at trial, based upon all the arguments, documents, facts, evidence, witnesses, surveillance tapes, etc. All that will be available in discovery. If serious about getting him counsel, and if this is in SoCal courts, feel free to contact me.
Related Questions & Answers
-
What is the statute of limitations for sexual battery in California? I want to... Asked 9/03/09, 8:22 pm in United States California Criminal Law