Legal Question in Criminal Law in California
Homicidal Ideation and Law
Is having homicidal ideation grounds for arrest?
2 Answers from Attorneys
Re: Homicidal Ideation and Law
Not by itself, but it can be grounds for civil commitment (involuntary psychiatric evaluation) under some circumstances. Such a commitment is is not the same thing as an arrest.
Re: Homicidal Ideation and Law
No.
Homicidal Ideation. I'm assuming you mean that someone is thinking about killing someone (you?), and you're wondering whether you can have someone arrested pre-emptively before the irrversable harm occurs. The answer is that we don't [yet] criminalize thoughts, without a corresponding step toward the commision of the crime. However, in certain circumstances, you don't have to wait until the homicide's complete before a crime is complete. There are attepmts and conspiracies, for example, that constitute completed crimes themselves. So I'd need more information to determine whether enough steps have been taken, and under what conditions, to constitute such an inchoate crime.
However, most importantly, you can get a restraining order against someone, so that if he or she comes within your vicininty, you can have him or her arrested with nothing more. This is exactly why we have these Emergency Protective Orders. Get one.
Contact me if you need more help, and good luck.
JACQUELINE GOODMAN RUBIO
www.californiadefenselawyer.net
Related Questions & Answers
-
Misdemeanor - Domestic Violence I am a 21 year old male college student who... Asked 3/22/08, 6:53 pm in United States California Criminal Law
-
Bf on meds and accused... BF is first time offender. Acted out based on panic,... Asked 3/21/08, 6:53 pm in United States California Criminal Law