Legal Question in Criminal Law in California
Can a superior court judge disregard a supreme court case ruling that has not been repealed and is say 70years old or even older?
2 Answers from Attorneys
"Disregard"? No. But if the case is no longer valid for some reason (for example, if new statutes require a different result) she can recognize that fact.
Sometimes one side will claim that a prior decision says something it really doesn't. More commonly, the two sides will legitimately disagree about what the prior case means. When a superior court rejects an argument based on a prior Supreme Court case, it does not mean she is disregarding the case. It usually means she doesn't agree with what a party said about it. Actual disregard is rare, but it does happen.
He CAN do anything he likes. If you disagree with a ruling or outcome, and claim the judge made a mistake of fact or law, you have the right to appeal and let the courts decide.
Related Questions & Answers
-
I have a problem I was ticketed for a 647f I was at a bar and had a drink then... Asked 3/05/14, 10:51 pm in United States California Criminal Law