Legal Question in Employment Law in California

Personal Business on-line

A couple of months ago I was warned by my employer that an on-line personal profile I have in a public friends website (MySpace.com) could jeopardize my career if my co-workers (I am a manager) were to view it. In that profile there is nothing pertaining to my work other than what my profession is. It is a non-sexual profile nothing more than what I enjoy doing - like hiking or dinner dates. I use it to keep in touch with old friends and to make new friends. Anyone in that website can see pictures and profiles of who my friends are. Can my employer terminate me for being in a public website during my personal time?? I have no control of who is entering that website and of who can view my profile. I feel it's no different than if I were at a nightclub in Hollywood getting drunk and a couple of my co-workers happened to walk in and view that. Then mentioning that at work. My employer told me that I am a company manager at ALL times and that I must behave accordinly whether I'm at work or not! Even on-line! And even in my neighborhood bars because it's a small world and a co-worker could be present!


Asked on 9/15/05, 11:16 pm

3 Answers from Attorneys

Thomas Pavone Pavone & Cohen

Re: Personal Business on-line

The other responses you have received are accurate. I would add a simple warning: The fact is that as an at will employee you serve at the pleasure of your employer, subject to statutory and case law that protects you from discrimination, harassment and retaliation. However, because a manager is often evaluated on a number of different levels, don't think for a moment that an employer could not determine that they have lost confidence in your ability to manage - without ever referenceing your off duty activities. As you move up the corporate ladder, your activities might cause you to be viewed as not demonstrating management material. In short, anything you do can be a factor in a management decision and most management will be thoughtful enough to make sure that they have another, nor-controversial reason for their decision.

Read more
Answered on 9/16/05, 6:51 pm
Patrick Turner Patrick E. Turner Inc. APLC

Re: Personal Business on-line

This area of the law is currently unsettled. The issue is whether an employer can take adverse employment action based upon otherwise legal conduct an employee may engage in in their off duty hours. There is a labor code provision which provides that an employer cannot take adverse action against an employee based upon what they do outside of work, but a California appellate court has held that the statute refers only to "constitutionally protected" activities. In short, there is no simple answer to your question at this point in time.

Read more
Answered on 9/16/05, 3:09 pm
Terry A. Nelson Nelson & Lawless

Re: Personal Business on-line

You are entitled to your personal life as described, and probably could make a valid claim if terminated as threatened. The law may not be 100% clear, but it is more strongly in support of employees than employers in this area.

Read more
Answered on 9/16/05, 3:16 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Labor and Employment Law questions and answers in California