Legal Question in Personal Injury in Illinois
My dog bit another dog while the dog was being walked past our house. Our dog was not on a leash, he ran out as my husband was coming in the house. The owner has presented us with a $400+ vet bill, and brought the dog back a second time to the vet and incurred another $250 bill. How far can he take this? We agreed to pay the initial $400; do we have to pay every expense for this dog, and can he eventually sue us?
2 Answers from Attorneys
A dog is personal property much like a car. The maximum that you are legally responsiblr for is the market value of the dog.
If you have accepted responsibility for your dog's bitting another one, then you have accepted responsibility for all expenses that are the natural result of that bite. You certainly have the right to talk to the vet and inquire about the necessity of whatever procedures that have been presented to you. Further, you have absolute right to call other vets and see whether the same procedure can be done cheaper and pay the lesser amount. You also have the absolute right to hire your own vet and have the dog examined and assess what are the injuries and prognosis and what, if any, future care is needed.
If you do not accept responsibility, then you may get sued at which time you will have to defend yourself. But, the other side who has sued you has the burden of proving that the damages and costs they have asked you to pay are in fact related to the incident.
I hope this helps-