Legal Question in Civil Rights Law in Washington

I was in an accident with someone DUI, I didn't have insurance, who is at fault?

I was waiting to turn left at a green light, 4-way intersection, no turning lanes. Oncoming driver had his blinker on to turn to my right and appeared to be turning, so I went. The next thing I know, my airbags had deployed and my 2 children were screaming in the back seat. The other driver moved his vehicle and came to my car and said that he did not want to prosecute or involve the police. I did not have insurance at the time. I found out from state patrol, while sitting in the EMT truck, that he was being arrested for DUI, and he and his passenger were not injured. Other than an abrasion on my face that scarred, soreness and bruising, my children and I did not receive any serious injuries. My driving record was perfect, no prior tickets or accidents. I was cited for failure to yield, and no insurance. I have received a letter from his inusurance for the cost of repairing his vehicle, and medical costs are pending. Is he at fault because of the DUI? Am I responsible for paying this? Do I have a case? How do I find a lawyer?


Asked on 12/12/05, 12:43 am

1 Answer from Attorneys

Christopher Steuart IT Forensics, Inc.

Re: I was in an accident with someone DUI, I didn't have insurance, who is at fault?

The issue of fault would be determined by a fact finder (judge, jury, arbitrator, etc). The fact description you have provided would support his being at fault, but that does not mean you win (on failure to yield and on civil liability), only that the facts as you have described them would support your winning. The other driver may tell a different story (and who the fact finder believes is unpredictable). I can say that his intoxication would go some ways to showing that his faculties (ability to operate vehicle correctly, perceive events and recall events) may have been impaired (the higher his BAC the stronger this argument gets). One of the benefits of insurance is that they will pay for your defense in a civil suit. Your winning the failure to yield (your infraction) and his losing his DUI (criminal charge) would raise doubts with his insurance company on the civil liability (but is not determinative). The failure to have insurance is also an infraction, and you would clearly lose on that (although even that may be dismissed if you are found to not at fault and get insurance in a reasonable time). I practice in Kitsap County, and done DUI and traffic cases. We should talk.

Read more
Answered on 12/12/05, 2:06 pm


Related Questions & Answers

More Civil Rights Law questions and answers in Washington